Erich Oswald Stroheim came to America in 1909 at the age of 24 and added a "von" to his name, elevating his Viennese Jewish parents from milli-ners to royalty. He invented stories about his
cavalry exploits when, in fact, he had been declared unfit to hold even a
corporal's position in a transport unit.
His imagination and storytelling ability plus a penchant for fabricating
meticulous details, even about a life he hadn't led, enabled him to create nine
motion pictures (all but one silent) and attain a position in the pantheon of early
Hollywood idols.

Richard Koszarski (right) revisits the work of Erich von Stroheim, pioneering film actor, director and writer
Right photo by Nick Romanenko
|
Richard Koszarski, an assistant professor of English, has revisited the life of
von Stroheim in a revised and expanded edition of a book he wrote in 1983, now
titled "Von: The Life and Films of Erich von Stroheim" (Limelight Editions).
The earlier book, "The Man You Loved to Hate," was based on primary
documents, cross-checked against eyewitness testimony and contemporary
accounts in industry trade papers and other period sources, says the author. In
the current book, a third of the material is completely new or significantly
rewritten. The revised text also makes use of documents uncovered by the von
Stroheim family only recently, he adds.
Koszarski's fascination with this icon of Hollywood's silent era began during
his undergraduate days and continued through his doctoral studies at New York
University in the early 1970s. "What made von Stroheim valuable as an object of
study is that at that time there was a real dilemma about understanding
Hollywood and the potential of the film industry to produce art. Scholars were
questioning whether art could be produced in the industrial context of Hollywood
studios. An ideal model was von Stroheim, who fought the system for his entire
career and whose struggles with MGM over 'Greed,' his adaptation of Frank
Norris' 'McTeague,' were legendary."
Koszarski notes that von Stroheim kept returning to the same themes,
characters and dramatic situations, suggesting the work of a painter or novelist.
"Only Chaplin thought to use the cinema in this manner. In this sense, he was
like an independent filmmaker of today. In his day he was chided for 'repeating
himself,' but looking back we can agree that he was 20 years ahead of everyone
else in Hollywood," says the author, who spent much of his career developing
the American Museum of the Moving Image in Astoria, Queens.
According to Koszarski, von Stroheim's directing career reached its apex with
"The Merry Widow," released in 1925. In it, he mastered "the leap from Frank
Norris to Franz Lehar" and "demonstrated a command of style beyond the range
of any of his contemporaries."
Von Stroheim, however, "never recalled the film with any affection and took
every opportunity to demean the picture, its star, the production company and
his own role in the proceedings." He later implied that the project had been
forced on him, despite the fact that it was his own idea.
The director's relations to Hollywood were always tempestuous, notes
Koszarski. Even as he was making "The Merry Widow" in one corner of the
MGM lot, in another corner the studio was recutting his film "Greed" and
throwing the pieces away. In 1999, Koszarski worked with Turner Classic Movies
on a four-hour reconstruction of the film using still photographs from the cut
sequences.
Every single film was a struggle and a compromise for the inflexible von
Stroheim, and every film has a different explanation for what happened,
Koszarski relates. Sometimes he ran into the censorship machinery, sometimes
he went way over budget or had arguments with studio heads, including the
powerful Louis B. Mayer of MGM.
"Some of von Stroheim's films might only contain a third of what he wanted or
were finished by somebody else, and in some cases they are damaged or lost.
My dilemma was how do I write about this man when all his films are corrupted,"
says Koszarski, who often went back to the original script drafts and cutting
continuity drafts, which show how a film was edited week by week, to reconstruct
von Stroheim's original intent.
"In my work, I tried to establish the truth about how his nine films were made,
not just because he was an interesting man and I like the films, but because I
might be able to understand how the system was operating and why people who
came a little later, like Howard Hawks and John Ford, were able not to evade the
system but turn it to their own ends."
Von Stroheim was also a highly successful actor, known for his portrayal of
the prototypical Hun, using a whole arsenal of "obnoxious Teutonic
mannerisms." In his earliest films, he is already leering behind his monocle,
primping, strutting and holding himself ramrod stiff. "Audiences were being
taught to hate the character, but this soon transposed to hating the man,"
Koszarski observes.
His acting roles included one of the most unnerving scenes in film history. In
the "Heart of Humanity," von Stroheim, as the German soldier, is tearing off the
uniform of a Red Cross nurse prior to raping her when he is maddened by the
cries of an infant locked in the room with them. He walks over to the cradle,
picks up the child and throws it out the second-floor window. It is a scene that few in any audience, in any era, can forget.
Von Stroheim directed his last film in 1932, although he continued to act
sporadically, both in Europe and the United States. Indeed, the high point of his
acting career was a strangely autobiographical role in Billy Wilder's 1950 film
"Sunset Boulevard," with Gloria Swanson, for which he received an Academy
Award nomination as Best Supporting Actor, the only Hollywood kudo von
Stroheim ever received.
Films directed by Erich von Stroheim
>
Silent
Blind Husbands (Universal) 1919
The Devil's Pass Key (Universal) 1920
Foolish Wives (Universal) 1922
Merry-Go-Round (Universal) 1923
Greed (Goldwyn; released by Metro-Goldwyn) 1924
The Merry Widow (MGM) 1925
The Wedding March (Paramount) 1928
Queen Kelly (Gloria Productions/United Artists) 1928
Sound
Walking Down Broadway (Fox) 1932